000 04111naa a22005177i 4500
001 UMUN-OA-20261005-PH-012
003 local
005 20261005174912.0
006 m o d
007 cr||||||||||||
008 261005s2024 xx o u000 0 eng d
024 7 _a10.1093/heapro/daae049
_2doi
035 _a(local)EuropePMC:PMC11132294
040 _alocal
_beng
_clocal
041 0 _aeng
100 0 _aVirginia Braun
_eauthor.
245 1 2 _aA critical review of the reporting of reflexive thematic analysis in Health Promotion International. /
_cVirginia Braun; Victoria Clarke.
264 1 _a[Place of publication not identified] :
_bOxford University Press,
_c2024.
300 _a1 online resource (1 article).
336 _atext
_btxt
_2rdacontent
337 _acomputer
_bc
_2rdamedia
338 _aonline resource
_bcr
_2rdacarrier
500 _aPublication type: Review article.
500 _aLinked open-access copy: published version.
506 0 _aOpen access; no subscription required for the linked open-access version.
_fUnrestricted online access
_2star
520 3 _aUsing the concept of methodological congruence-where the different elements of a study 'fit' together-we explore both problematic and good practice in (reflexive) thematic analysis (TA) as reported in Health Promotion International (HPI). Aligning with the importance we place on 'owning your perspectives' we situate this exploration in relation to our understanding of the variation in approaches to TA and qualitative research more broadly. This contextualization is necessary for highlighting why we judge practices to be in/congruent, and to facilitate more knowing congruence in future research. We critically reviewed a 'sample' of 31 papers published in HPI between 2010 and 2023 citing Braun and Clarke as reference for TA. We overview a range of problematic and good features of the use of TA in HPI, before focusing on two domains that seemed to present key challenges: theory and themes. Methodological incongruence can occur when postpositivist values and practices unwittingly creep into ostensibly non-positivist TA; we encourage thoughtfully and what we term 'knowing' consideration of theory, and quality practices and criteria. Methodological incongruence can also occur through mismatched conceptualizations of themes-notably, the use of 'topic summaries' as themes for reflexive TA (and fragmented thematic structures with 'thin' themes). We provide examples from the reviewed papers to demonstrate good practice in researcher reflexivity, articulation of theoretical and methodological frameworks and congruent themes. However, mindful of power dynamics, we only discuss problematic practice in general terms, to protect author anonymity. To facilitate thoughtful, quality TA-of all kinds-we provide eight pointers for researchers (and reviewers) to guide quality practice, and facilitate the use of concepts, procedures and criteria that promote knowing methodological congruence.
540 _aCreative Commons Attribution. See the linked licence for the applicable terms.
_uhttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
546 _aIn English.
588 0 _aDescription generated from Europe PMC bibliographic metadata retrieved on 5 October 2026; full text linked from the source.
590 _aCourse allocation: B. Sc. Public Health.
650 4 _aCoding
650 4 _aSaturation
650 4 _aTheme
650 4 _aMethodological Congruence
650 4 _aTopic Summary
650 4 _aSmall Q Qualitative
653 _aB. Sc. Public Health
653 _aUMUN open access collection
653 _ahealth promotion
655 4 _aReview articles.
700 0 _aVictoria Clarke
_eauthor.
773 0 _tHealth promotion international
_gVol. 39, no. 3, (2024), pages/article daae049
_x0957-4824
856 4 0 _uhttps://europepmc.org/articles/PMC11132294
_yRead open-access publication
_zOpen access.
_70
884 _aCourse selection and automated MARC21 enrichment from Europe PMC metadata.
_g20261005
_khttps://europepmc.org/articles/PMC11132294
_qlocal
942 _n0
999 _c1284
_d1284