000 04497naa a22005057i 4500
001 UMUN-OA-20261005-NS-053
003 local
005 20261005174910.0
006 m o d
007 cr||||||||||||
008 261005s2023 xx o u000 0 eng d
024 7 _a10.1136/bmjopen-2022-070639
_2doi
035 _a(local)EuropePMC:PMC10030738
040 _alocal
_beng
_clocal
041 0 _aeng
100 0 _aMichele Villa
_eauthor.
245 1 0 _aReporting quality of abstracts from randomised controlled trials published in leading critical care nursing journals: a methodological quality review. /
_cMichele Villa; Massimo Le Pera; Tiziano Cassina [and others].
264 1 _a[Place of publication not identified] :
_bBMJ Publishing Group,
_c2023.
300 _a1 online resource (1 article).
336 _atext
_btxt
_2rdacontent
337 _acomputer
_bc
_2rdamedia
338 _aonline resource
_bcr
_2rdacarrier
500 _aPublication type: Review article.
500 _aLinked open-access copy: published version.
506 0 _aOpen access; no subscription required for the linked open-access version.
_fUnrestricted online access
_2star
520 3 _aObjectives To evaluate the methodological quality of randomised controlled trial (RCT) abstracts in leading critical care nursing journals against the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials-Abstracts (CONSORT-A) checklist and to identify variables related with abstract reporting quality. Design Descriptive methodological quality review. Data source We searched the PubMed database and the websites of each included journal. Eligibility criteria We included RCT abstracts published between 2011 and 2021 in the first 11 Scopus-ranking (2021) critical care nursing journals that reported the results of RCTs in English that referred to the care of adult patients with acute/critical illness or their relatives and/or caregivers and conducted in ICUs. Data extraction and synthesis Two independent investigators extracted the data using a prespecified 17-item checklist directly derived from CONSORT-A. For the primary outcome, each item was evaluated whether it was adequately reported or not and descriptive statistics were reported. An overall score was calculated by summing the results of all items and multivariate linear regression was conducted to detect potential predictors. Results Seventy-eight RCT abstracts were included in this review. The items with the highest CONSORT-A adherence were authors, objective, conclusion, participants, interventions and outcome. The randomisation item had the lowest CONSORT-A adherence, followed by trial registration, funding source, harms or side effects, recruitment, blinding and outcome results. The average CONSORT-A score was 8.5±1.5 points (of the maximum 17.5 points). Multivariate analysis indicated that the categorised word score and publication date were positively associated with the overall CONSORT-A score, while the first author's country being in Asia was negatively associated with the overall CONSORT-A score. Conclusions The 78 RCT abstracts showed poor overall adherence to CONSORT-A. The results indicate that the methodological reporting quality of RCT abstracts in critical care nursing journals requires improvement to facilitate assessment of the applicability and relevance of the results reported.
540 _aCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial. See the linked licence for the applicable terms.
_uhttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
546 _aIn English.
588 0 _aDescription generated from Europe PMC bibliographic metadata retrieved on 5 October 2026; full text linked from the source.
590 _aCourse allocation: B. Sc. Nursing Science.
650 4 _aepidemiology
650 4 _aStatistics & Research Methods
650 4 _aAdult Intensive & Critical Care
653 _aB. Sc. Nursing Science
653 _aUMUN open access collection
653 _acritical care nursing
655 4 _aReview articles.
700 0 _aMassimo Le Pera
_eauthor.
700 0 _aTiziano Cassina
_eauthor.
700 0 _aMichela Bottega
_eauthor.
773 0 _tBMJ open
_gVol. 13, no. 3, (2023), pages/article e070639
_x2044-6055
856 4 0 _uhttps://europepmc.org/articles/PMC10030738
_yRead open-access publication
_zOpen access.
_70
884 _aCourse selection and automated MARC21 enrichment from Europe PMC metadata.
_g20261005
_khttps://europepmc.org/articles/PMC10030738
_qlocal
942 _n0
999 _c1260
_d1260