Cedric M J Ryngaert

International cooperation by (European) security and intelligence services: reviewing the creation of a joint database in light of data protection guarantees / Cedric M J Ryngaert; Nico A N M van Eijk. - 1 online resource (1 article).

Publication type: Journal article. Linked open-access copy: published version.

Open access; no subscription required for the linked open-access version.

Increasing multinational cooperation between intelligence and security services, including the establishment of a joint database on (alleged) jihadists, raises legal concerns over the protection of personal data, in particular with respect to the allocation of responsibility among participating states, the geographic scope of fundamental data protection norms, and the applicable law. It is argued that states participating in multinational cooperative efforts may share responsibility, eg in relation to a shared database. However, for reasons of proximity, the host state of the server has heightened duties of care. It is also argued that where a participating state, in particular the host state, exercises virtual control (jurisdiction) over an individual person’s data, such a state has data protection obligations towards that person, regardless of the latter’s location. Participating states, and again in particular the host state, are under an obligation to put in place adequate control systems, including with a view to preventing the transfer of data that have been gathered by states in breach of data protection guarantees. If systemic failures in the multilateral system are identified, states are barred from transferring data to the system, unless they can obtain credible guarantees that data will be adequately protected. General principles of data protection law, derived from case law as well as general or sector-specific regulations, govern the processing and transfer of data in the context of multinational intelligence cooperation, including the management of a joint database. There is no reason not to apply them in the context of national security. National intelligence and security services are stepping up their cooperation to address national security threats, in particular terrorism. Given the sensitivity of national security, such cooperation will normally occur on the basis of legally non-binding, informal arrangements rather than ‘hard’ treaties.1 Under these arrangements, states scale up the exchange of data concerning persons of interest. Most notably, the Counter Terrorism Group (CTG), which consists of the EU Member States plus Norway and Switzerland,2 has activated a database containing personal data of (alleged) jihadists travelling to, or returning from particular conflict areas. The database is (near) real-time available to all CTG participating services. In 2017, an operational platform was formally opened, which allows for more detailed multilateral consultations. This operational platform is also available to all CTG participating services.3 This database is fed by all participating states,4 but its server is based on the territory of just one of them, in The Netherlands, hosted by the AIVD, the Dutch General Intelligence and Security Service.5 In terms of set-up, the database somewhat resembles the database established by European police services and managed by Europol.6 These developments raise acute questions as to the adequate protection of data by multiple cooperating states, in particular as to the locus of responsibility in case of breach and the required level of data protection. In essence, four legal questions arise: (1) What form of responsibility for data breaches does the non-binding informal cooperation envisaged by the security services yield?; (2) Do the individuals whose data are processed fall within the jurisdiction of the participating states, ie do these states have human rights obligations vis-à-vis the individuals concerned, who may well happen to be outside the territory?; (3) Under what circumstances is the responsibility of the database manager engaged when he processes deficient data from participating states, and vice versa, under what circumstances is the responsibility of a state engaged when it transfers data to a deficient international database?; (4) What substantive guarantees as to the level of data protection and the management of the database need to be provided, and in particular from what legal regime are they to be drawn (the legal regime of the server’s host state, an international legal regime …)? This article, which is based on an expert opinion of the authors to the Dutch Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services (CTIVD),7 is relevant for cooperation among all security and intelligence services. Its emphasis, however, lies on the exchange of data between European states, defined here as states that are Contracting Parties to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), or at least the exchange of data accompanied by the creation of a centralized database of which the server is located on the territory of an ECHR Contracting Party. The geographical limitation to ECHR Contracting Parties allows us to review the envisaged cooperation in light of the jurisdictional and substantive guarantees provided by the ECHR, as notably developed by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). The authors have also taken into account the extensive legislation and case law of the European Union (EU) on data protection in order to develop an appropriate normative framework. The authors bear in mind that according to the Treaty on European Union (TEU), EU law does not govern national security matters as such.8 Accordingly, from a it does not apply to the envisaged of cooperation between intelligence and security services. national security is not from the scope of the of Rights of the European Union (the including by the European Court of based on the the legal developments at the level of the EU may for the cooperative arrangements with which are The cooperation between EU police services, accompanied by the creation of the database managed by EU on the basis of an EU which for extensive data protection can be in is based on applicable international law and law, in particular with respect to questions of jurisdiction and by sector-specific from and data protection law. This the of the The the of responsibility on the basis of non-binding, cooperation between intelligence and security services. The the individuals whose data are the database fall within the jurisdiction of of the participating The in the context of data what responsibility is engaged for breaches to data and responsibility are with in the and in the context of data The data protection what substantive data apply in the context of the establishment of the database. are in the to national security are Accordingly, states are to share data such at least on the basis of legal However, such need not to informal arrangements that are not legally such as or of they address that are to be returning for such international cooperation may well be in of the law, states have into informal cooperative arrangements of international legal It is that national intelligence and security services to cooperation the exchange of data, including the establishment of on the basis of informal cooperative This informal multilateral cooperation the responsibility for data is who obligations to an adequate level of data and who is in case of Under law, ECHR Contracting Parties are not barred from international This exchange intelligence in the context of national relevant case law that states are from up an international cooperative in such a that individual rights are In order to adequately human the for a level of protection that is at least to the level of protection normally by the This is as the based on the of the to an international or adequate the participating states or states which obligations under the of the will not be This does not apply when the state does more than just and exercises The was developed in the context of the transfer of to an (the This is a international legal person, which may responsibility in its However, the of the of international cooperation with the of adequate rights guarantees to of international This the informal as envisaged by intelligence and security services, which does not a legal with a If that is


Creative Commons Attribution (licence family recorded by the source; version not supplied in metadata).


In English.

10.1093/idpl/ipz001 doi


data protection
national security
host state responsibility
data transmission
EU data protection law
counterterrorism

B. Sc. International Relations UMUN open access collection international cooperation


Journal articles.