What should a liberal economist (not) do? Sen–Sugden debate on welfare economics /

Valentina Erasmo

What should a liberal economist (not) do? Sen–Sugden debate on welfare economics / Valentina Erasmo; Paolo Santori. - 1 online resource (1 article).

Publication type: Journal article. Linked open-access copy: published version.

Open access; no subscription required for the linked open-access version.

Abstract The discussion between Amartya Sen and Robert Sugden has produced valuable insights into liberal economic and philosophical theory, yet it remains relatively overlooked in scholarly literature. Our paper seeks to fill this gap. Both authors advocate for a normative theory emphasizing the freedom–opportunity relationship as an alternative to welfarism. Sugden contends that his criterion of opportunity is procedural and anti-paternalistic, whereas he seems to consider Sen’s capability concept to be substantive and inadvertently paternalistic. Sen argues that this perceived difference is exaggerated and stems from a misunderstanding of his ideas. The dialogues between Sen and Sugden, both implicit and explicit, highlight two key questions: What are the origins of their differing views? What should a liberal economist’s role be? Our paper will explore these questions through the lens of the Sen–Sugden debate in normative economics, reinterpreted within their respective moral and political philosophies.


Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives (licence family recorded by the source; version not supplied in metadata).


In English.

10.1093/cje/beaf023 doi


Amartya Sen
Robert Sugden
capability approach
welfarism
paternalism
economic liberalism

B. Sc. Politics, Philosophy and Economics UMUN open access collection welfare economics


Journal articles.